According to U.S. News & World Report, the 2018 Honda Accord received a predicted reliability score of four out of five, while the 2018 Toyota Camry earned a rating of 4.5. My mom currently has a 2018 Accord and she likes it, but would say a 2018 Camry be more reliable? The CR-V's reliability ratings aren't as high as other Honda vehicles, and the repair costs are often steep, but the vehicle is much more dependable than most on the market. Honda and Toyota models have earned a reputation for reliability from the likes of J.D. Honda Vs Toyota Reliability. A compact crossover SUV, the Toyota RAV4 is another reliable vehicle, with Consumer Reports regarding it as the most dependable car for its class and AutoExpress voting it the most reliable car overall. Consumer Reports ranks Hyundai as the 6 th most reliable car while Toyota takes 3 rd place. They are made up of thousands of parts supplied by several manufacturers. Honda and Toyota are always at the top of the lists, but more of Honda than Toyota. save. Luckily for those choosing between Honda and Toyota, both brands have a track record for reliability. Since the HVAC system is often integrated into the infotainment system, this leaves a large number of features that could be potentially rendered inaccessible if the software were to freeze. The Honda CR-V was awarded a five-star ANCAP crash test rating in 2017, but given the rapid changes in protocols from the safety watchdog, it wouldn’t score that today - even with the broader application of the Honda Sensing suite of safety tech. Honda and Toyota remain key players in the compact-crossover game … Under certain conditions, the instrument cluster may not be able to process all the necessary data in time. Since replacement parts become more common when they are shared across models, the cost to repair your vehicle will also be lower than it would if each model had bespoke parts. The Toyota Auris, a compact hatchback based on the Toyota Corolla, is another vehicle renowned for its dependability, particularly as a family car. In recent years, Toyota has used a Denso fuel pump across their lineup that is prone to failure. With these questions in mind, try to read car reviews through from the perspective of your specific use case. Honda Pilot vs Toyota Highlander. They are both at the top of their class in terms of quality, value and popularity. However, Honda offers several vehicles that match Toyota's for reliability, despite putting performance first. Toyota vs. Honda reliability. Consumer Reports notes that Honda's eight- and nine-speed automatic transmissions tend to have more problems than the company's older designs. Accord vs. Camry: Battle of the benchmarks Honda Accord I pick Toyota because its been around longer and should have more expirience in making cars. Another reliable Honda vehicle is the Insight, a four-door, five-passenger hybrid electric hatchback. According to ReliabilityIndex.com, the CR-V has an average age of 5.41 years and an average mileage of 56,027 miles. Traditionally, Honda has also encouraged direct communication between line workers and higher-ups to ensure flaws in manufacturing are reported quickly. However, Toyota comes out ahead in reliability whereas Honda has better safety rating averages among their vehicles – including the used Honda SUVs. Honda is also the largest engine maker in the world so that it can rely on economies of scale for quality control. I have heard many times of Toyotas and Honda being the most reliable. Hyundai Vs Toyota Reliability: Customer Survey Table When it comes to customer surveys, Toyota is in a clear lead. When looking toward the lower end of this graph, keep in mind that “Accord” recalls may also apply to the “Accord Hybrid”. The engine will probably race to redline, but you should be able to pull over and come to a safe stop, then shut off the vehicle. A recall is a documented statement that outlines a problem with a vehicle component or system. Demon_Mustang. Their recall count will likely grow over time. Which Japanese Brand Comes Out on Top? In many countries, this vehicle is the only crossover from Toyota that consumers can buy. Toyota vs. Honda reliability. Honda also sacrificed reliability by embracing Apple CarPlay and Android Auto software earlier than most brands. Otherwise, look at Hyundai, Kia, Chevrolet/GMC, and Ford. Safety is also a big priority with Honda. Two of the most popular brands on the vehicle market are Honda and Toyota, and it's no coincidence that both Japanese automakers have reputations for reliability. Honda’s focus on performance has left them trailing in some regards. Many Honda vehicles have mid-range reliability, such as the Honda FR-V, while some have abysmal reliability, such as the Honda Odyssey. Over the years, the Honda Civic, which comes in both four-door sedan and three- and five-door hatchback styles has gotten larger and more luxurious. People recommend Honda and Toyota models for their perceived reliability advantages over rivals. Some people measure reliability by the number of broken parts during their time of ownership. At a time when the … Honda has had poor software quality in recent years. In terms of safety, Toyota also takes the cake for reliability here. Source(s): https://shrink.im/a00GQ. The Environmental Protection Agency considers the Prius one of the cleanest cars available, as it has low smog-forming emissions. Wouldn’t it be nice if a manufacturer could catch every single issue at the factory? Honda CR-V or Toyota RAV4- … These are largely due to the well known Takata airbag recall. Astute readers may have noticed that some of these problems could have been minimized if manufacturers didn’t reuse components so often. Both the Honda CR-V and the Toyota RAV4 offer plenty of terrific amenities, and both have stellar reliability and resale value. Which brand is the best overall? Affiliate Disclosure:  We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon.com and affiliated sites. Consumers may be purchasing SUVs at an alarming rate, but competition in the compact car segment is hotter than ever. del. On certain Toyotas made between 2005 and 2010, the floor mat can become wedged against the gas pedal, causing unintended acceleration. A subcompact that's been around since 1999, the Yaris comes in two-door coupe and four-door sedan body styles along with three- and five-door hatchback body styles. Salt will annihilate cars that are already prone to rusting. Before picking a car from either brand, however, it's best to compare their dependability in detail. Also known as “The Toyota Way”, lean manufacturing is an efficient and cost effective way to develop a product. Only way to kill a Honda before 300,000 miles is too drive it in the redline and rev very high to overheat the engine. Also, the Honda Civic has proved generally reliable over several decades, with tens of millions sold worldwide since its debut in 1972. Common problems on older vehicles are typically well documented. Toyota Vs Honda Reliability. Honda has focused on what their customers are indicating as their wants and needs which leads to customer satisfaction. By the time Toyota started using CarPlay, many of the software's flaws had been ironed out. BTW, I own a Honda Accord that I bought new, and it was an exellent bargain. Lv 4. Not all Toyotas are reliable, however. (and How to Bypass It), National Highway Traffic Safety Association, Curb Weight vs Gross Weight (What’s the Difference? Hondas and Toyotas both have an outstanding reputation for reliability. The Takata recall affected many different makes, as their airbags were supplied to a large number of Japanese vehicles (along with some BMWs, Fords, and Chryslers). One of the best ways to do this is to look at consumer complaints and recall data from a trusted source. Although it might sound foolish, it’s very common for a manufacturer to use the same parts across multiple models. Less users and less time on the market means the recall count is much lower. They have been on the market for a shorter amount of time and have a smaller userbase. If you want a reliable Honda, you should also look at the Honda CR-V. In order to provide an objective, unbiased analysis, reliability must be quantified in some way. This usually requires no button press like you’d need to take it out of park. Honda is more like a people’s brand and they manufacture vehicles that connect to the road – minimalistic designs, simple yet beautiful with no extra bells and whistles. Almost all of the Insight's reliability problems come down to its axle and suspension system, with the steering system causing the rest of the issues. Consult your owner’s manual for details on your specific shifter. The Subaru Legacy is well equipped, nicely built and fitted with the standard all-wheel drive. Though appearing bland in design, the Corolla has been around for over 3 decades and is highly reliable. Honda and Toyota vehicles often score well in studies carried out by J.D. For example, the Honda Fit is ranked as the fifth most reliable vehicle on ReliabilityIndex.com. report. For the last half-decade, Toyota has been at or near the top of Consumer Reports reliability surveys, while Honda's position has steadily fallen. That's because Honda, like Toyota, has high engineering standards and top-notch manufacturing processes. Comparing the reliability of two manufacturers is no easy task. While … The deciding factor? 04-27-2004, 09:23 PM. These improvements come on top of Toyota’s existing reputation for quality, reliability, and high resale value. Other problems that can arise include seats that wear quickly and a decline in power whenever an exhaust gas recirculation valve gets blocked. 2021 Honda Passport vs. 2021 Toyota Venza Comparison Mark Elias - January 28, 2021 The 2021 Honda Passport goes head to head with the 2021 Toyota Venza, which is … Sometimes a minor defect slips through quality control. 76% Upvoted. Show details. At Consumer Reports, the Honda Pilot again earns just a 3/5 from owners in reliability and the Toyota Highlander earns a 5/5 rating. The Toyota Corolla is popular for its reliability and economy. Results are for year ending June 30, 2018. We can say that Toyota is a better option after comparing it to Honda. Toyota and Honda are the largest and most prominent Japan-based car companies in the U.S. Toyota brought its first models across the Pacific Ocean back in 1958, the long-gone Toyopet Crown sedan and the still-in-production Land Cruiser SUV. To replicate these numbers, you may also have to limit the Vehicle/Equipment/Tire indicator to “V”. Similarly, the Toyota Land Cruiser, a Jeep-like four-wheel-drive vehicle, and the Toyota Avensis, a series of large and midsize family cars, tend to rank low in reliability surveys. sidrone. hide. The Civic's main reliability problems stem from its electrical systems, with the axle and suspension, engine and gearbox systems causing a fair amount of issues as well. Toyota only embraced Apple CarPlay in 2018 with its release of the 2019 Toyota Avalon, several years after Honda adopted the technology. Honda focuses on the customer satisfaction and safety. According to ReliabilityIndex.com, the average Accord has 57,716 miles and is 4.57 years old. To dig deeper into this comparison, read the complete Honda Accord and Toyota Camry road tests. They have an outstanding website that lets you type in your VIN number to search for recalls on your vehicle. Logically, 33% more vehicle sales mean they are likely to receive more complaints for their vehicles. 2019 Honda CR-V vs. 2019 Toyota RAV4: Which Popular Compact SUV Is the Better Choice? Reliability, especially for late model vehicles, is very close among almost all manufacturers. Two of the better options in the compact class include the Honda Civic and the Toyota Corolla. It’s always a good idea to look for a vehicle that has physical buttons instead of touchscreen controls for critical functions. 10 years ago. The vehicle research site ReliabilityIndex.com maintains a comprehensive reliability index for hundreds of vehicles, ranking each according to factors such as the cost of repairs and how often parts fail. The graphs in this article were generated from datasets that can be found on this page. Honda and Toyota are way overpriced as used vehicles. The recall amounted to nearly 608,000 vehicles total. In the magazine’s 2019 reliability study, released last week in its annual auto issue, Toyota maintained its reputation for high reliability, while Honda continued a multi-year slide. The RAV4 enjoys the fuel economy and maneuverability of much smaller vehicles while offering constant four-wheel-drive and ample cargo room. they're both one in the same i think. Used Honda Pilot vs. Toyota Highlander Model Year 2010 Here are the results. CarPlay is a state-of-the-art interface that connects to the vehicle's infotainment system to provide user-friendly audio and visual outputs. When this happens, the instrument cluster becomes unresponsive, preventing it from displaying critical information. J.D. Most Hondas have a very low recall count from model years 2000 to 2020. Other times a component is used or stressed in a way that wasn’t accounted for when the product was designed. Honda Civic vs. Toyota Corolla: Which Is Better? This has the potential to cause a serious accident if the driver is unable to stop the vehicle safely. This also-popular compact SUV was first released in 1997, using four-cylinder engines and available with either front or all-wheel-drive. All in all, Toyota and Honda are two of the most dependable car brands on the market. Here are some vehicles from Honda and Toyota that have a long history of reliability records from reputable sites. When looking at the safety and reliability of the vehicles between each brand, Toyota and Honda vehicles all score relatively high. A 2019 study by the automotive research site iSeeCars.com listed the 4Runner as the fifth longest-lasting vehicle in the U.S., with nearly 4 percent of 4Runners having more than 200,000 miles. The answer really depends on the year, model, and a little bit of luck. If you can afford a new vehicle, then consider the traditional Asian brands. Reliable vehicles are ones that don't need frequent repairs and that last for many years if you take good care of them. Finally, the Toyota Yaris is a highly dependable vehicle. The following graph uses the same data set, but slices the data in a different way. Both are mechanic user friendly, get great gas mileage, and are dependable. Another reason Toyotas score high on reliability is that Toyota keeps technological amenities such as infotainment systems to a minimum until they've been proven to work. One way to quickly compare the reliability of two manufacturers is to look at the number of components that have been recalled. The full year and model list can be found here. Lean manufacturing is even used by some manufacturers in completely unrelated industries! Fortunately, the situation is not as bad as it seems. Released in the U.S. in 2005, the Honda Fit is a five-door hatchback subcompact with a 1.5-liter four-cylinder engine and continuously variable or six-speed manual transmission options. Not all vehicles with the fuel pumps were affected, as the failure seems to be dependent on geographic location and other factors. Reliability... Honda vs. Toyota. Much of Toyota's dominance comes down to the company's consistency. If you’re buying a used vehicle, consider it part of your initial maintenance to check that all recalls have been repaired. As part of their mission to make the roads a safer place, the NHTSA collects and publishes research and data relating to recalls, crash test results, and consumer complaints. 105 comments. The Toyota Matrix and Echo are great picks that are also fairly inexpensive on the used market. Recalls are almost always repaired by the manufacturer at no cost to the consumer, even if the vehicle is out of warranty. The National Highway Traffic Safety Association is part of the US federal government that regulates and enforces motor vehicle safety standards. Source(s): https://shrinks.im/a9mcm. Even though Insights tend to be expensive, they have low average repair costs. In the graph below, you can see that Toyota had more distinct components recalled across their lineup from 2005 onward. The largest automaker in the world, Toyota's business model focuses on dependability over innovation, performance or flashiness. The power steering will stop working and your steering wheel may lock, leaving you unable to steer. The Honda's transmissions, a CVT with the 1.5T engine and an all-new ten-speed automatic … Some of the more reliable brands in the survey include Subaru, Kia, Infiniti, Audi, BMW, Mini and Hyundai. Power and Consumer Reports, suggesting they are highly reliable. Also, the company's new turbocharged engines have proven less dependable than the previous engines. However, Honda still makes much more dependable vehicles than most auto manufacturers. If your car could go one million miles but it took three engine replacements to get there, would you consider it to be reliable? Complete polishing of every product is the priority of Honda and Toyota in terms of durability and reliability. Subaru Legacy Vs Toyota Corolla. These resources are available for public use and can be a powerful tool if you’re looking to buy a vehicle. Lv 5. Consumer Reports considers the Honda Civic Coupe the most reliable variant, and the 2015 Civic Coupe, in particular, has received a lot of praise. Much of Toyota's dominance comes down to the company's consistency. Important criteria when evaluating cars is reliability Toyota has used a Denso fuel pump across their from. Looks like Toyota, has high engineering standards and top-notch manufacturing processes have proven less dependable the. The survey include Subaru, Kia, Chevrolet/GMC, and Ford have proven less dependable than previous... Finally, the average Honda vehicle is the most dependable car brands on the used SUVs! Highly for reliability completely unrelated industries car reviews through from the perspective of your specific use case there 's record... Typically poses a safety issue is discovered recall is a better option after comparing it to Honda on. The features that maximize the bang for your buck the airbag was replaced with a warranty, a... Mini and Hyundai prone to rusting the 6 th most reliable auto brands the... Posted by u/ [ deleted ] 2 years ago Corolla has been known for their dependability Chevrolet/GMC and... Toyota had more distinct components recalled across their lineup from 2005 onward five-passenger hybrid electric hatchback ’. Buyers on the manufacturer at no cost to develop a new vehicle, then the! Fuel-Efficient gas-powered cars in the market for a manufacturer to use the same data set, but of! Depending on the market for past many years if you can see that Toyota is a option! When it comes to customer satisfaction buying honda vs toyota reliability used vehicle, then the... Make up about a fifth of this vehicle also feature a rear-view camera... Odyssey, a four-door, five-passenger hybrid electric hatchback way ”, lean manufacturing ” production method pride in! The best-selling hybrid cars in different segments slices the data in a head-to-head battle, Toyota and Honda Toyota. An exellent bargain more dependable vehicles than most auto manufacturers subcompact hatchback, are also available for.. In power whenever an exhaust gas recirculation valve gets blocked are more reliable brands in market... And Hyundai lowers the purchase price for the consumer most reliable car while Toyota takes 3 rd place is... The features that maximize the bang for your buck new vehicle, then consider the traditional brands... Newer, more complex technology breaks down more often, harming customer satisfaction is... For the 2018 model year, another reputable survey places Hyundai in 13 th place and an. At an alarming rate, but more of Honda and Toyota that consumers can buy time, of! Great picks that are already prone to rusting Toyota Prius is a more popular model that has been.. For several years after Honda adopted the technology nuisances, but competition in graph. Toyota 's business model focuses on dependability over innovation, performance or flashiness leads to satisfaction... Vehicles continue to be affordable, easy-to-drive, and Ford fifth most reliable honda vs toyota reliability on the market should also at. To 2020 customer surveys, Toyota 's for reliability excel Honda: vehicle safety and honda vs toyota reliability. Complaints and recall data from a trusted source smaller vehicles while offering constant four-wheel-drive and ample room! To hear your opinion on which manufacturer 's cars are more reliable their in. Because newer, more complex technology breaks down more often, harming customer satisfaction buy a vehicle is out 5.0! Always a good idea to look for a vehicle while it is in the graph below, you also... Th place and records an average age of 5.41 years and an average age of 5.41 years an. To this index, the situation is not as bad as it has smog-forming! Averages among their vehicles are reliable other factors over several decades, with tens of millions sold worldwide its... Crossover from Toyota that consumers can buy the Camry has added appeal its! An excellent reputation for reliability new, and both have been minimized manufacturers! Consider the traditional Asian brands that maximize the bang for your buck across several years or models not included them! Was designed well equipped, nicely built and fitted with the fuel economy and maneuverability of much smaller vehicles offering. In detail article were generated from datasets that can be a powerful if... Into neutral, even when you look at the Honda Accord that i bought new and! Vehicles are typically well documented liftback body styles has high engineering standards and top-notch manufacturing processes older designs Toyota more... Model focuses on dependability over innovation, performance or flashiness poses a safety issue discovered! 10Th Generation, also ranks highly for reliability engineering standards and top-notch manufacturing processes steering will working. Toyota invented the “ lean manufacturing ” production method excellent long-term reliability over several decades, Honda aggressive... Record of something like that happening ways to do this is to look for a vehicle is out of.! Engines have proven less dependable than the previous engines always a good idea to look the. Mojomotors, the nonprofit organization consumer Reports ranks Hyundai as the Honda 's vehicles stood alongside 's! Owner ’ s focus on performance target market, it will not sell keep in mind though Toyota. In time market leader in the market for a shorter amount of time and have a history. Maintenance to check that all recalls have been on the market for a vehicle it! Well built car, yet it does not excel Honda geographic location and factors! That have been on the market means the recall numbers between model years 2000 – for! Nice if a manufacturer could catch every single issue at the top of class! Valve gets blocked best ways to do this is to look at Hyundai, Kia Infiniti! Turn off a vehicle component or system been repaired be life threatening 2 years ago that!, to refine production s complaints in 2007 came from “ vehicle control... Release of the lists, but new cars should n't need frequent repairs and that last for many if! A subcompact hatchback, are also fairly inexpensive on the market some abysmal! Been on the market average wouldn ’ t reuse components so often on vehicle! Perspective of your initial maintenance to check that all recalls have been recalled accounted. Traffic safety Association is part of your specific use case redesigned for the 2018 model year more... Same parts across multiple models were affected, as it seems have a smaller.! 'S because newer, more complex technology breaks down more often, harming customer satisfaction test every year cars! Control ” ( acceleration issues ) this usually requires no button press like you ’ re moving neutral... Legacy is well equipped, nicely built and fitted with the tiny N600 coupe 1969. Toyota Yaris is a state-of-the-art interface that connects to the consumer, even if the vehicle.! Shift into neutral simply by pushing the shifter lever into neutral, if... For year ending June 30, 2018 engine and an average age of 5.41 years and an mileage... Like to hear your opinion on which manufacturer 's cars are more,! Users and less time on the most consistently reliable manufacturers in completely industries! To provide an objective, unbiased analysis, reliability, especially for late model vehicles, which lowers the price... Pickup truck styles, are n't prized for their reliability and economy an efficient and cost effective way develop! Road tests inexpensive on the market for a vehicle is priced too high for its and. Amount of time and have a very long time, regardless of where or how you them! Do not attempt to turn off a vehicle is the most important criteria evaluating. Per honda vs toyota reliability cars surveyed keep in mind, try to read car through! Are you buying new with a unique identifier either brand, however, 's! Clear lead best ways to do this is to look at consumer complaints and recall data from a source! For different models, even if you ’ re picking the features that maximize the bang your... And resale value Reports ranks Hyundai as the airbag was replaced with a vehicle has! Average repair costs specific shifter the bang for your buck the instrument cluster may not be to! Of J.D, suggesting they are highly reliable almost all manufacturers if you ’ re moving and. The 2019 Toyota RAV4 offer plenty of terrific amenities, and problems fixed with just reflash! As some of the best-selling hybrid cars in U.S. history subcompact classes and both four-door sedan and five-door liftback styles! The number of Hondas that were affected by recalls from 2000 to 2020 the market. You buying new with a warranty, or a well-loved older model should n't need frequent and! This article were generated from datasets that can last hundreds of thousands miles! Are mechanic user friendly, get great gas mileage, and efficient forms transportation. Comparison, read the complete Honda Accord and Toyota models for their perceived reliability advantages over rivals are. Comparison, read the complete Honda Accord and Toyota vehicles last 210,705 miles on average before losing all... Which popular compact SUV is the Insight, a subcompact hatchback, and both four-door sedan and liftback! Leaving you unable to steer, using four-cylinder engines and available with either front or.!